Yeh jo bhes hai tera…

The year was 2004, and I first saw the trailer of Swades on the TV.

It seemed like an interesting film, and I was impressed that Shah Rukh Khan would take up the film, something that was totally out of his comfort zone.

He was done playing the Lover Boy in Europe, the Lover Boy with a daughter, the Lover Boy with students, the Lover Boy who dances in a troupe, and the Lover Boy who knows all about loving his family. Quite clearly, he needed to do something different.

It must have been quite a bold decision for him to make. The film wasn’t being made by the Johars, or the Chopras. Ashutosh Gowariker, fresh from the colossal success that was Lagaan, had both directed and produced it. Shah Rukh Khan did not wear colourful clothes that seemed to be stolen from a Gay Pride parade, and he didn’t stretch his hands out in the trailer.

My name is Khan, but I love playing Jesus Christ”

It was a clear departure from the kind of films he had been churning out for more than a decade. I wondered if he was finally waking up to the fact that he could not dance around trees after reaching the age of 40. That he was looking for more grounded roles, and sensible cinema.

Though I didn’t go in with a lot of expectations, the film managed to capture my interest from the beginning.

It had an interesting premise, that of a NASA employee who comes to visit his childhood maid, and the experience transforms him. While the above description does not sound terribly exciting, it was a charming story.

There were no evil Zamindars, no Ramu Kaka, no weeping mothers with arati plates and the curtains flying. It was a simple story with a heart, and resorted to no gimmicks or unnecessary histrionics to move the story forward.

The biggest surprise of the film was Shah Rukh Khan. Now, whether you love him or hate him, Shah Rukh Khan is in your face throughout the year. Terrible as his choice of films may be, one cannot deny the fact that he has got tremendous screen presence. In Swades, he comes across as genuinely likeable.

Forget Kajol and Rani Mukherjee, the chemistry that SRK shared with the actress Gayatri Joshi (where on earth is she??) is the most I have seen with any actress he has shared screen space with. The two didn’t break into song in Holland or Greece at the drop of a hat, but there was enough in the plot to keep the tension going.

The soundtrack by Rahman is one of those less popular, but superior ones that vanish behind the Jai Ho and Naadaan Parindey.

The film did not have a fight in the climax, and no item numbers, and yet, when the film came to an end, there was a general sense of satisfaction I felt.

But the empty halls and poor reviews told another story. Taran Adarsh, the genius who said Ra.One has ‘soul’, and that ‘Rascals’ is hilarious, used all his film critiquing acumen to say, “The story of SWADES would’ve been ideal for a documentary…”

Even though some of the critics raved about the film, Swades eventually flopped.

Ashutosh Gowarikar took a sabbatical for four long years. And Shah Rukh Khan went back to his Om Shanti Om and Rab Ne Banadi kind of films.


Now, when I see films like Ra.One, or SRK monkeying around at Filmfare awards in a Sheila costume, I wonder if he’d be doing this if Swades had gone on to become a hit?

4 thoughts on “Yeh jo bhes hai tera…

  1. rjsays

    Nicely done. Swades is one of my favorite movies, ranks highly at the top alongside Wednesday & Sholay. Regarding SRK, it is easy to criticize him, but I think he tried doing ‘good’ roles a few times and retaliated back to his stupid lover-boy image ‘coz only that has worked for him. Swades was not his first outside-the-comfort-zone venture, but it was Dil Se — remarkably amazing movie (with really really good music) which was the biggest flop of the year (I was a kid and I asked my Dad to go to that movie, “bahut violence hai. bekar movie hai.” And we resorted to watching hum aapke hai kaun and karan arjun during those days… after the failure of the brilliant Dil Se, he reverted back to his image, and tried again with Swades, which was a massive flop again, and he went back to his usual self. I think SRK is a brilliant actor (Dil Se, Swades, Chak De) who chooses to act stupid and gay because apparently, Indians like shit. Sad.

  2. Pranav Karnad (@Jakradum)

    Well, that was lucidly put. I love nearly everything about ‘Swades’. I can recollect some scenes word-for-word, and I watch it almost ritually about once every year. The film really transcends barriers set my Indian mainstream cinema, and goes on to walk around the zones of being truly ‘world cinema’.
    Now, it is sort of more than obvious why films like these stopped doing well a long time ago. (Case in point- Kaagaz ke Phool, if you have seen it). We as a society don’t want to be reminded of our follies and the shit that we swim in everyday. Realism, in cinema, as Mrinal Sen argued out in his film ‘Akaler Sandhaney’, is entertainment for the rich. Proves why a film like ‘Slumdog Millionaire’, sappy as it may be, is wow-ed only abroad for its ‘honest’ portrayal of slums (something that never went well with Amitabh Bacchan). Again, case in point- Nargis Dutt criticised ‘Pather Panchali’ and the rest of Ray’s Apu trilogy; saying that he shows India in poor light.

    As cinema-goers, we’ll always embrace escapism. Illogical stories in luxurious set-ups. Just helps the average working man to forget the shit in his life. That’s the kind of cinema he will PAY to watch.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.